When blaming yourself just won’t wash

Posted onJuly 10, 2013

Mechanic fails in his attempt to win damages for injuries resulting from his own actions as sole company director

A motor mechanic who lost a finger working in his company's workshop has failed in his attempt to win damages from his insurers, after trying to claim for his own negligence as the sole company director.

Peter Brumder tried to win damages from his company insurers after his finger was severed by a hydraulic ramp, on the basis that the Company was in breach of their statutory duty to maintain the hydraulic ramp in efficient working order.

But although the Company had breached their absolute statutory obligation to maintain equipment in efficient working order, the claim was unsuccessful because the court ruled that Mr Brumder, as sole director and shareholder of the Company, was in breach of his obligation to exercise reasonable care to enable the Company to fulfil its obligations.

The case of Brumder v Motornet went all the way to the Court of Appeal, where the claim was dismissed on the grounds that as a director of the company, Mr Brumder should have been aware of his health and safety duties and by failing in those, he had breached his duty as a director under the Companies Act 2006. He was a wrongdoer and he could not gain advantage from his own wrongdoing.

Said corporate litigation expert Andrew Flagg of Eastbourne solicitors Stephen Rimmer LLP : "The statutory obligation to maintain work equipment is an absolute duty. If you are running a business on your own, it's no good thinking that it's only me and I'll be careful. Sole directors and sole traders must take steps to ensure that they are fulfilling their statutory obligations and keeping up to date with legislation and ensuring equipment is properly maintained."

Brumder v Motornet [2013] EWCA Civ 195

Content note:

This is not legal advice; it is intended to provide information of general interest about current legal issues.

Mr Jerome Soucek provided us an exemplary professional service. He was very courteous, knowledgeable and very approachable.
Thank you Andrew. I am beyond delighted!! Breathing a huge sigh of relief. Whopping thanks
We are all very grateful for the tremendous amount of work that you have done and the total attention to detail that you have shown. You are a pleasure to do business with
A very friendly efficient service with tireless attention to detail throughout, excellent.
Thank you for giving such excellent service and for steering us through the legal situation with which we were confronted. Andrew Flagg was professional, yet approachable. Explained the intricacies of the law in clear terms and was endlessly patient with our questions. Thank you Andrew, you have been brilliant!
I would recommend Stephen Rimmer to anyone who required solicitor help. Jack Prosser was such a great help to us as we tried to buy a property. Jack always gave great detail which we could understand and was very quick at replying to any queries we had. In the future, I will certainly be using Stephen Rimmer/Jack Prosser again.
We have just completed on our house sale and purchase with Jack, he has been totally amazing and gone over and above to get our house sale through. I would highly recommend him and will definitely be using him for future conveyancing needs. Thank you so much.
Jack has been invaluable in making sure our sale/purchase went through, demonstrating endless patience and professionalism. We wouldn’t use anyone else in the future!
She was well informed and did her homework on the case before seeing me. She was on site and didn’t fill my brain with jargon.
Fantastic service, very supportive and reassuring.
Most professional, considerate, empathetic and competent. Thank you very much!
A repeated but well meant ‘Thank you’, I appreciated your sensitive and supportive manner in handling my defence.
…charming, encouraging and very professional.
…shown immense kindness and confidence. Throughout the court case it was clear what an incredibly bright and gifted advocate you are. Thanks to you I am still employed in the job I love, I owe you a huge debt.
Thank you for your calming influence and advice as well as your expertise. Thank you very much indeed for all you have done.
Thank you again for your excellent representation, we can’t thank you enough!
You have been informative, very helpful and spot on!
Jay is a fantastic Lawyer, he definitely loves what he does and he’s very skilful and awesome.
Thank you so much for saving my life! You treated this case like your baby right from the first day and you supported me all through the way. Those memories of the 2 weeks of trial would stay with me till I die, I kept wondering what would happen to my children if I lost this case, but you kept me strong with your words and your dedication to your job is outstanding. I am forever indebted to you Jay, I owe you so much!
Jay was exceptional throughout. In the most difficult circumstances, I could not have asked for a more experienced, competent or reassuring team on my side.